
“Public Enemies” (1929 - 1969)
Episode 3 | 1h 51m 21sVideo has Audio Description
The exploits of outlaws fill the headlines and the FBI promise to wage a war on crime.
The exploits of gangsters like Al Capone and outlaws like John Dillinger fill the headlines, which makes them folk heroes in their own time and the FBI launches a public relations push to build support for its “war on crime.”
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...

“Public Enemies” (1929 - 1969)
Episode 3 | 1h 51m 21sVideo has Audio Description
The exploits of gangsters like Al Capone and outlaws like John Dillinger fill the headlines, which makes them folk heroes in their own time and the FBI launches a public relations push to build support for its “war on crime.”
See all videos with Audio DescriptionADProblems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Crime and Punishment in America
Crime and Punishment in America is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Measuring Crime and Punishment
How does the way we collect and measure crime shape our understanding of it? Crime statistics can tell us how crime changes over time. But the way crime is measured, defined, and communicated can also shape public perception and policy.Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipAnnouncer: Major funding for "Crime and Punishment in America" was provided by... The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and the Park Foundation.
Major funding was also provided by the following members of The Better Angels Society: The Fullerton Family Charitable Fund, The Just Trust for Education, Allan and Shelley Holt, The Tow Foundation, and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support was provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities, The Arthur Vining Davis Foundations, and by The Better Angels Society members: John and Catherine Debs, Timothy Fazio, Lise Strickler and Mark Gallogly, the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund, and these additional funders.
"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible, in part, by contributions to your PBS station from Viewers Like You.
Thank you.
Viewer discretion is advised.
The following program contains graphic violence which may not be suitable for all audiences.
[Music] Reginald Dwayne Betts: Most of us don't think about dignity in our everyday lives.
And for me, it's the ability to be in community.
Dignity is having a self.
A loss of dignity is one of these transformative experiences, right?
Like, you, literally, don't know it until it's happened to you.
It happens profoundly in different circumstances for everybody.
So if you've been evicted and you have your property on the sidewalk.
And for people who have been in prison, it gets stripped in all kinds of different ways.
For a lot of us, the moment before we went in prison becomes the last time maybe that some of us felt truly dignified, or felt like we had the capacity to make our family, our friends, or ourselves feel like, you know, we had a place in the world.
And If you don't have dignity, how can you be free?
Franklin Delano Roosevelt: A prison to us is no longer a bastille to keep people in indiscriminately, and our object ought to be to turn them out as better citizens than when they went into prison.
J. Edgar Hoover: The Federal Bureau of Investigation is waging a relentless warfare against crime and criminals.
Newsreel reader: The king of the gangsters is about to be taken for a ride by your Uncle Samuel.
William Parker: You see, crime in America is skyrocketing.
It is not a question of the proficiency of the police.
It's a question of the indulgences of the American people.
Policeman: Get your hands up, I said.
Drop that purse and get your hands up.
L.D.
Barkley: We are men.
We are not beasts, and we do not intend to be driven or beaten as such.
Doris Tate: We must fight for victims' rights, and we know the victims have no rights.
Speaker: The crime rate isn't going down.
Violent crime was up 10% across the country last year.
Ronald Reagan: We must make America safe again.
It's time to get these hardened criminals off the street and into jail.
Woman: How do you ask somebody to forgive you for something that is almost impossible to forgive?
Bill Clinton: When you commit a third violent crime, three strikes and you are out.
Bill Bratton: I'm sensing a fear among American police forces that we are losing the streets.
Betts: Everybody says, "Why'd you do it?"
But we never have reasons, never good ones.
♪ Fiorello La Guardia: We are now ready for a showdown on Prohibition.
After over 11 years of a dismal failure of this so-called noble experiment, we maintain that the American people have a right to decide finally upon the question.
Narrator: By the late 1920s, most Americans, including many who had once supported Prohibition, agreed with New York Congressman Fiorello La Guardia that it had been a mistake.
It had turned millions of people into law-breakers, filled the nation's prisons and jails, and spawned corruption on a scale the country had never seen.
Rival bootlegging gangs battled in the streets, murders filled the headlines, and crime became a national issue.
For the next 40 years, as the country weathered the Great Depression, the Second World War, the Cold War, and the upheaval of the 1960s, the public's anxiety about lawlessness and disorder would grow, and fear of crime would become a driving force in American life.
Through it all, Americans would continue to grapple with how criminal laws were enforced and whom the justice system served.
Caleb Smith: The United States has been an experiment in political liberty for some and also a whole series of experiments in captivity for others.
It's the place where the deserving are separated out from the unworthy.
And we have those who are protected on one hand and those who are culpable on the other hand, those who enjoy the benefits of the law and those who suffer the violence of the law.
And that is as central to the history of this country as anything else.
♪ [vehicle horn honking] Narrator: At 10:30 in the morning on February 14, 1929, in a garage on the North Side of Chicago, gangsters lined seven rivals up against the wall and shot them.
The brazenness of what the newspapers called the "St.
Valentine's Day Massacre..." [Camera shutter clicks] and the graphic photographs of the crime scene shocked the country.
♪ The case was never solved, but most people believed the killings had been ordered by the most famous gangster in the country, Al Capone.
♪ Capone controlled most of the bootlegging, prostitution, and gambling in Chicago, and like Jesse James before him, loved to be quoted in the newspapers.
Voice: Some call it bootlegging.
Some call it racketeering.
I call it a business.
They say I violate the Prohibition law.
Who doesn't?
All I ever did was sell beer and whiskey to our best people.
Some of the leading judges use the stuff.
They talk about me not being on the legitimate.
Nobody's on the legit.
Don't let anybody kid you into thinking I can be run out of town.
I haven't run yet, and I'm not going to.
Al Capone.
Narrator: Unlike Capone, most gangsters avoided the spotlight.
Voice: Our boys were given strict orders to behave properly.
We tried to keep them from fighting and showing off.
They had to keep clear of the cops.
We tried to get them to be disciplined.
And we were very strict with our outfit.
Meyer Lansky.
Narrator: Meyer Lansky and Lucky Luciano were the most powerful mobsters in New York City.
They had risen through the ranks of small-time Jewish and Italian gangs in one of the city's poorest neighborhoods, Five Points.
When Prohibition went into effect, they had become big-time bootleggers--wealthy beyond their wildest dreams.
High-profile killings like the St.
Valentine's Day Massacre attracted too much attention, which was bad for business.
Determined to stay out of the headlines and avoid unnecessary bloodshed, Luciano and Lansky began meeting with other gangsters from around the country: Al Capone from Chicago; Bugsy Siegel and Frank Costello from New York; Boston's King Solomon; Boo Boo Hoff from Philadelphia.
They declared a truce and established a national crime syndicate.
The gangsters agreed to divide the country into territories and established rules for mutual cooperation, along with punishments for anyone who broke those rules.
Luciano was in charge of the syndicate, but he rejected the traditional title Boss of Bosses.
Lansky, who became known as the mob's accountant, instituted sophisticated financial practices, including money laundering and offshore banking.
Voice: We were in business like the Ford Motor Company.
Shooting and killing was an inefficient way of doing business.
Ford salesmen didn't shoot Chevrolet salesmen.
They tried to outbid them.
We had long ago decided to follow the same principles-- to use guns or violence as infrequently as possible, or, better still, never to use violence at all.
Meyer Lansky.
Narrator: Largely thanks to Luciano's vision and Lansky's business acumen, crime was now organized on a national scale.
The federal government did not know that the secret crime syndicate existed.
Still, Republican President Herbert Hoover wanted to show the public that his administration was serious about fighting crime.
He ordered the Treasury and Justice Departments to get the man he considered the most dangerous criminal in America-- Al Capone--off the streets.
But the police in Philadelphia got to him first.
When Capone passed through the city in May of 1929 and decided to go to the movies... [Camera shutter clicks] police arrested him outside the theater for possession of a concealed pistol.
He was convicted and sentenced to a year behind bars to be served at the century-old prison that had once been celebrated as a wonder of the modern world: the Eastern State Penitentiary.
The perpetual isolation that had horrified Charles Dickens when he visited Eastern in 1842 had long since been abandoned.
Like most American prisons and jails, Eastern was severely overcrowded.
But Capone got special treatment-- an outsized cell in an area reserved for high-profile prisoners the staff called "Park Avenue."
Narrator: When Capone emerged from prison in 1930, he found himself in a very different world.
♪ The stock market crash of 1929 had set off the worst economic crisis in American history-- the Great Depression.
Simon Balto: People are stealing bread to feed their families.
That's a punishable crime.
You have children literally running into a store and running out with a coat in the middle of the winter because they're freezing to death.
And that's a punishable crime.
And, you know, it's people who are trying as best they can to simply live.
People were being evicted from their homes at incredible rates.
Poverty is just becoming even more widespread, and so that's what police are being dispatched to deal with.
In some cities, police officers are not even getting paychecks regularly because city budgets have been eviscerated by austerity measures.
Narrator: Nearly half the nation's banks failed.
One in four Americans lost their jobs.
Thousands rode the rails and roamed the streets in search of work, something to eat, a place to sleep.
Shantytowns, nicknamed Hoovervilles, sprang up all over the country.
The federal government had no relief programs to help the millions of desperate Americans struggling to survive.
In many cities, the owners of illegal businesses did what they could to help.
Gus Greenlee, bootlegger, numbers king, and owner of the famed Negro League baseball team the Pittsburgh Crawfords, opened a soup kitchen.
So did Al Capone.
♪ Roosevelt: So first of all, let me assert my firm belief that the only thing we have to fear is fear itself, nameless, unreasoning, unjustified terror which paralyzes needed efforts to convert retreat into advance.
Narrator: In 1933, President Franklin Roosevelt was inaugurated, promising a New Deal for the American people.
His goals were ambitious: stimulating the economy, saving the nation's banking system, and putting social programs in place to ease the ravages of the Depression.
He also signed the 21st Amendment, repealing Prohibition, and he declared a war on crime, vastly expanding the federal government's jurisdiction and its law enforcement capabilities.
Roosevelt approved new federal prisons, including a fortress in San Francisco Bay where Al Capone would eventually be sent for tax evasion-- Alcatraz.
Beverly Gage: Alcatraz was designed to illustrate and affect this story of specially dangerous criminals who needed to be isolated from American society-- these kind of super villains, who were going to need their own sort of supermax prisons and, in fact, their own forms of law enforcement.
Rebecca McLennan: In the space of about two or three years, no fewer than 10 federal statutes were passed creating new federal crimes, including grand theft auto, the Lindbergh Act criminalizing interstate kidnapping.
So New Deal liberalism involves building prisons and building out the policing power of the state.
Narrator: Several law enforcement agencies-- the Bureau of Investigation, the Prohibition Bureau, and the fingerprint division-- were merged into one: the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
To run the FBI, the president chose the bureaucrat who had gotten his start rounding up suspected radicals after the First World War: J. Edgar Hoover.
Hoover would stay in the job for four decades and become the most powerful law enforcement official in American history.
The Federal Bureau of Investigation is waging and will continue to wage a relentless warfare against crime and criminals, dedicated to one purpose and one alone-- the protection and safety of the law-abiding citizens.
Gage: It's really in the 1930s that the FBI fully enters criminal law enforcement in the ways that we think about it doing today.
The FBI is sent into bank robbery; it's sent into kidnapping cases that cross state lines, a whole series of new areas of jurisdiction.
Narrator: The Bureau also focused on statistics, collecting data from police departments across the country and creating annual reports on crime in America.
Gage: Hoover recognized that if you were in charge of crime statistics, you could, essentially, be in charge of defining crime.
He would find a way to describe crime being on the rise.
He would give you a very firm number about that.
And, amazingly, that was something he said, not like, "Oh, I guess we're not doing a very good job," but, that was "Give me more appropriations.
We've got to fight this war on crime even more aggressively."
Narrator: To win public support for the war on crime and for FBI agents, now called G-men, the Justice Department launched a massive PR campaign.
♪ Newsreel reader: Washington.
Youth fights lawlessness.
25 visiting New Yorkers join the anti-crime club of J. Edgar Hoover of the Department of Justice.
David, I'd like to know what your impressions have been in the studies that you've carried on in New York.
We went to the prison of New York City, and I saw men behind bars, and the other fellows agree with me that crime does not pay.
Well, Jack, what do you gotta say for yourself?
I'm so short, I'll have to get up on the box.
All right, Jack on the box.
Let us know what you know about crime, about the conditions in New York.
Gee, Mr.
Hoover, your G-men sure are good.
I'd like to be one when I grow up.
Well, Jack, if you continue to work hard, play hard, and live clean, we'd be mighty proud to have you as a G-man.
Thank you very much, Mr.
Hoover.
Narrator: Hoover and his G-men made a list of the men and women they considered the greatest threats to public safety in America, the kidnappers and bank robbers whose sensational crimes filled the headlines: Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow, Baby Face Nelson, Pretty Boy Floyd, and John Dillinger.
Dillinger spent nine years in prison after assaulting and robbing a family friend.
When he was paroled at 29, Dillinger formed a gang and embarked on a year-long crime spree, robbing banks from Ohio to South Dakota and breaking out of jail three times.
Gage: John Dillinger became something of a folk hero not only for being a poor guy who would steal money from the rich and from the banks but also because he seemed so effective at defying the law and defying the police.
And, in fact, he managed to break out of the jail where they had promised they would hold Dillinger.
Narrator: With each escape, Dillinger's legend grew.
Narrator: At Little Bohemia Lodge, Dillinger and his gang escaped through this rear window and ran off looking for a car.
To Mr.
and Mrs.
Mitchell, who tells how Dillinger and his gang commandeered their car.
Mrs.
Mitchell: He said, "We just came in to get a car.
We want to make our getaway here.
And he said to me, "Don't be afraid, mother.
"And you won't take cold because I'll put this blanket around you."
[Gunshots] Narrator: The FBI named Dillinger Public Enemy Number One in June of 1934.
[Pistols fire] One month later outside a Chicago movie theater, Hoover's agents caught up with him and shot him in the back.
Khalil Gibran Muhammad: There are a lot of working-class white people who can't make ends meet.
And while they certainly don't appreciate the gun violence that erupts on their streets, they admire the gangsters and they admire the serial bank robbers.
And so Bonnie and Clyde and John Dillinger become these kind of anti-heroes, who are bucking the system because the system is fundamentally unfair.
♪ Voice: The businessman thinks of himself as a respectable citizen and, by and large, is so regarded by the general public.
Even when they violate the law, they do not conceive of themselves as criminals.
In their confidential relations, businessmen speak with pride of their violations of law and regard the enactment of the law rather than the violation as reprehensible.
Their consciences do not ordinarily bother them.
Edwin Sutherland.
Narrator: In 1933, the Senate Banking Committee opened an investigation into the collapse of the financial system that had caused the Great Depression.
They exposed rampant corruption, speculation, and market manipulation on Wall Street.
The head of the National City Bank admitted that he and his colleagues had profited handsomely from short-selling their own bank's stock during the crash, paying no taxes on their big bonuses, rewarding themselves with interest-free loans, and reselling bad loans to unsuspecting customers overseas.
J.P.
Morgan Jr.
conceded that he had made stocks available at deeply discounted prices to powerful friends, including former president Calvin Coolidge and Supreme Court Justice Owen Roberts.
One reporter noted that the only difference between a bank president and a bank burglar is that one works at night.
The Depression-weary public was infuriated.
The financial industry was so loosely regulated that most of what the committee had uncovered was legal, and the titans of Wall Street wanted to be sure it stayed that way.
The president of the New York Stock Exchange, Richard Whitney, promised Congress that bankers and traders could continue to police themselves.
But the hearings did spur Congress to pass the Securities Act and the Glass-Steagall Act and to establish the Securities and Exchange Commission.
President Roosevelt put Joseph P. Kennedy, who had made a fortune manipulating the stock market before the crash, in charge of the SEC.
It takes one, Roosevelt said, to catch one.
Still, crooked financiers were rarely prosecuted and almost never convicted.
Richard Whitney was an exception.
To support his lavish lifestyle and to make up for losses from speculative investments, Whitney had embezzled hundreds of thousands of dollars from his father-in-law's estate, the New York Yacht Club, Harvard University, and from the Stock Exchange's own charitable trust funds.
In 1938, he was found guilty of grand larceny.
Newsreel announcer: The man whose downfall shocked the nation, Richard Whitney.
Now grim Sing Sing on the Hudson awaits him.
Nearing the big house, no private limousine for the former king of finance, who once owned nine.
Now he's just one of a batch of prisoners crowded together in a police-guarded car, as he arrives at the prison to serve a sentence of 5 to 10 years for grand larceny.
[Cell door closes] Narrator: At Sing Sing, Whitney was examined by prison psychiatrists, who concluded that he lacked any trace of remorse.
One of the leading criminologists in the country, Edwin Sutherland, believed Richard Whitney, and others like him, caused far more harm than the bank robbers and kidnappers on the FBI's public enemies list.
Sutherland came up with a new name for them: white-collar criminals.
Voice: White-collar crime is real crime.
Their criminality has been demonstrated again and again in the investigations of banking, public utilities, railways, munitions, the oil industry, and politics.
White-collar criminality is found in every occupation.
The financial cost of white-collar crime is probably several times as great as the financial cost of all the crimes which are customarily regarded as the "crime problem."
Although a million-dollar burglar or robber is practically unheard of, these million-dollar embezzlers are small-fry among white-collar criminals.
Edwin Sutherland.
Narrator: Sutherland had evidence implicating some of the wealthiest families in America-- DuPont, Firestone, Ford, Mellon, Morgan, and Rockefeller.
But he did not dare publish it.
Kevin H. Sharp: Bob Dylan said, "Steal a little and they throw you in jail.
Steal a lot, and they make you king."
There's a lot of truth in that.
And someone who is being prosecuted, under a white-collar criminal statute would be surprised to think of themselves as a criminal.
But it is clearly a crime; it is not a victimless crime.
There are people whose lives are destroyed, and they are destroyed financially, which, then, has its own ripple effect.
Larry Krasner: This is a world where a small number of people have more wealth than everybody else put together.
Our politics work around that.
Our economies work around that.
And the reality is that the court system itself responds to that.
The world's biggest financial manipulators and the world's biggest polluters, the world's biggest drug dealers, who work as executives in Big Pharma, who do terrible things that destroy lives, get away with it.
But we view some kid who is stealing chips and a soda from a convenience store as being a criminal.
That's, obviously, completely upside down.
[Siren] [Radio hums, static over radio] Roosevelt: Today's threat to our national security is not a matter of military weapons alone.
We know of other methods, new methods of attack.
The Trojan Horse.
The Fifth Column that betrays a nation unprepared for treachery.
Spies, saboteurs and traitors are the actors in this new strategy.
With all of these, we must and will deal vigorously.
Newsreel reader: Poland--September 1939... Narrator: World War II began in 1939 when Nazi Germany invaded Poland.
Within a few months, Hitler's forces overran much of Western Europe.
The United States was still officially neutral, but many feared that Germany and its allies--Italy and Japan-- were building a network of secret agents in America, a "Fifth Column."
One piece of the story, when we think about the big history of crime, punishment, law enforcement in the United States, is how much it's often driven by crisis-- the crisis of a war; worries about a foreign enemy; worries about a domestic enemy; worries about domestic insurrection.
And that crisis politics can often produce sets of policies and actions where the long-term implications haven't fully been thought through.
Narrator: Hoping to stop foreign spies from infiltrating America, Roosevelt doubled the budget for the U.S.
Border Patrol.
And even though the Supreme Court had prohibited the practice, he also secretly gave the FBI authority to wiretap without a warrant anyone it deemed a potential threat to the nation.
The FBI began surveilling the public on an unprecedented scale.
They collected millions of fingerprints, and spied on German, Italian, and Japanese nationals, as well as American fascists, Communists, civil rights groups, and union leaders.
They also compiled a list of people to be detained if America entered the war.
To do it all, the agency tripled in size, and recruited tens of thousands of informants to spy on their co-workers and neighbors.
Then on December 7, 1941... Japan attacked the American fleet at Pearl Harbor.
Newsreel reader: The mad Japanese dog strikes in the Pacific and Washington's State Department gives the incredible news to reporters, who had been awaiting news of peace negotiations with the sly, war-crazed Japs.
First reports of the surprise attacks stun the nation... Narrator: A few days after Pearl Harbor, agents from the FBI and the Border Patrol rounded up thousands of German, Italian, and Japanese nationals on the detention list the FBI had prepared.
Many were interrogated and released, but more than 23,000 were held in detention camps.
Voice: America is our only home.
We are pledged to her preservation and perpetuation.
Public sympathy may wear away and, perhaps, hate and prejudice will replace the present tolerance and forbearance.
We must prepare the hardest fight in our generation, a fight to maintain our status as exemplary Americans.
Mike Masaoka, Japanese American Citizens League.
Voice: The Japanese race is an enemy race, and while many second- and third-generation Japanese born on United States soil possessed of United States citizenship have become Americanized, the racial strains are undiluted.
A Jap's a Jap.
It makes no difference whether he is an American citizen or not.
I don't want any of them.
General John DeWitt.
Narrator: Army General John DeWitt, citing unfounded rumors of enemy subversion, demanded that all people of Japanese descent living on the West Coast be removed.
J. Edgar Hoover was one of the only officials in the administration who argued against removal.
Gage: His view was that mass internment, which involved both Japanese nationals and people of Japanese descent who were U.S.
citizens, was, obviously, unconstitutional, particularly as it concerned U.S.
citizens.
He also believed that the FBI already had all the answers, right?
It could tell you who was dangerous.
You didn't need to round up everyone.
And he did, to his credit, object to the fact that this seemed to be really a racial program.
Narrator: California's Republican Attorney General, Earl Warren, supported removal, because it was impossible, he said, to distinguish between loyal and disloyal Japanese Americans.
N. Bruce Duthu: We allow ourselves to be stirred up into a sort of a national frenzy because of these narratives of hate, narratives of distrust, narratives of, "This is a threat.
These folks are a threat."
Well, of course you're going to fabricate or easily become convinced that this is a people, distinguished by their race, who can't be trusted.
And they have to be segregated in much the same way that Natives were segregated on reservations.
Narrator: Ten weeks after Pearl Harbor, President Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066, authorizing the removal of all Japanese nationals and Japanese Americans living on the West Coast.
More than 120,000 men, women, and children, 70,000 of whom were U.S.
citizens, were forced to leave their homes and incarcerated in remote inland camps ringed with barbed wire and patrolled by guards with machine guns.
Elie Mystal: German Americans on the East Coast were not treated the same way that Japanese Americans were on the West Coast, even though German U-Boats were off the coast of New York during the war.
There was nothing that Japanese Americans living on the West Coast did to get interned.
Simply by being Japanese American and existing in a place was criminalized.
Narrator: A few Japanese Americans disobeyed the evacuation order.
One of them was a 23-year-old welder from Oakland, California, Fred Korematsu.
"I'd lived here all my life," he said, "and I was going to stay here."
Korematsu: I didn't feel that I was, I did anything wrong.
And if anybody did wrong, it was the law.
Because I figured it was unconstitutional what they were doing.
Narrator: To conceal his identity, Korematsu changed his name, claimed to be of Spanish and Hawaiian origin and even underwent plastic surgery.
But in May 1942, he was recognized while buying a pack of cigarettes at a drugstore and was arrested for violating the relocation order.
A few months later, Korematsu was found guilty in federal court.
He was given five years' probation and sent to the Topaz internment camp in Utah.
With the help of the American Civil Liberties Union, Korematsu appealed his conviction.
But the appeals court ruled against him.
He decided to bring his case to the Supreme Court.
By then, the United States had begun to win the war in the Pacific.
Some in the Roosevelt administration argued that the government should close the internment camps.
Others advised against taking any action until after the election in the fall of 1944.
President Roosevelt agreed.
For the sake of internal quiet, he said, the problem should be handled gradually.
[Applause] In November, Roosevelt was elected to an unprecedented fourth term.
On December 17th, the administration announced the termination of the mass exclusion of persons of Japanese ancestry from the West Coast.
The next day, the Supreme Court issued its ruling on Fred Korematsu's case.
By a vote of six to three, they upheld his conviction for violating Executive Order 9066.
The threat of espionage, they said, had justified the evacuation order.
Justice Frank Murphy, who 19 years before had presided over Ossian Sweet's murder trial in Detroit, dissented.
So did Justice Robert Jackson, who wrote the minority opinion.
Voice: If any fundamental assumption underlies our system, it is that guilt is personal and not inheritable.
Even if all of one's antecedents had been convicted of treason, the Constitution forbids its penalties to be visited upon him.
[Justice Robert Jackson] Duthu: Justice Jackson says the majority allowed racism to seep into our Constitutional rulemaking, and he says, "And now that principle, "if you can call it a principle, lies about like a loaded weapon."
Those are very powerful words to say that now we've set a precedent ready for the next administration or a subsequent Congress or a subsequent president to use when there's a parallel, to say, "There is now another threat that we must act upon, "and forget our commitment to equal protection of the laws, to due process of the law," and to say "Those rules have to be suspended because we have a crisis here."
That is a very real worry.
♪ [Guitar strumming] Singer: ♪ Bom bom boom ba bom ♪ Singers: ♪ All the day long, whether rain or shine ♪ ♪ She's a part of the assembly line ♪ ♪ She's making history, working for victory ♪ ♪ Rosie... ♪ [Man imitates riveter whirring] ♪ The riveter ♪ ♪ Keeps a sharp lookout for sabotage ♪ ♪ Sitting up there on the fuselage ♪ ♪ That little frail can do more than a male can do ♪ ♪ Rosie... ♪ [Man imitates riveter whirring] ♪ The riveter ♪ Narrator: During the war, millions of women entered the workforce for the first time, filling jobs vacated by the men who had joined the military.
Narrator: American women were making money, learning new skills, and living very different lives than they had before the war.
Melissa Murray: Sexual mores are loosening.
People are having sex outside of marriage.
Single people are having sex.
There's still a climate where access to contraception may be a little more uneven, but most women understand that if they find themselves requiring an abortion, there's a way to take care of it.
Narrator: It had been a crime to perform an abortion in every state since the 1880s, but there had always been doctors and midwives willing to do the procedure.
Unless their patients died, they were rarely prosecuted.
Heather Ann Thompson: Crime completely depends on what moment we're in in American history.
And it turns out that the criminal justice system is not just about public safety.
It is, in fact, as much about things like regulating morals, regulating the status quo.
And so after the war, when so many men come home from the war and there's a real return to this idea that we need to go back to more of the traditional family, women should get married now, they should have children, and so the criminal justice system is a place where you see this play out.
Narrator: Now women who terminated their pregnancies were seen as a threat to the sanctity of the American family, even as Communist subversives.
And enforcement of abortion laws became much more common.
Murray: Suddenly abortion becomes not just criminal but something that is deeply, deeply corrosive to society, and there's a crackdown.
Voice: "Chicago Daily Tribune."
Mrs.
Helen Stanko, 43, a midwife, was arrested yesterday by police, who said they found her in the act of performing an abortion in her home.
Policemen made the raid after detailed preparation.
They arrested nine women, one at a time, after they had left Mrs.
Stanko's home, and took them to a medical examination.
All made statements that Mrs.
Stanko had just operated upon them.
Murray: Some police departments have a whole abortion squad, where their entire charge is to stake out abortionists and to crack down.
So you have raids of makeshift abortion clinics, where the police come in and there's literally a woman on the table with her dress up in the middle of a procedure, and she's taken into custody.
Sometimes, pelvic exams are performed in order to determine that the woman was pregnant, so that you can actually establish that there was an attempted crime in progress.
Narrator: Doctors and midwives were arrested in high-profile raids, and their patients were compelled to testify against them.
Some lost their licenses and were sent to prison.
Murray: When they are punished, when they are raided in such a public way, it sends a signal to other people doing this: you could be next.
Narrator: Now any woman seeking to end a pregnancy would have to take even greater risks.
Good evening.
I'm Mike Wallace.
The show is "Night Beat."
Our first guest tonight is the chief counsel of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, Thurgood Marshall.
Are you a non-violent person?
Do you subscribe to that?
I subscribe to non-violence, but I'm not a pacifist.
I'm no more of a pacifist than our forefathers were in the Revolutionary War or that--in the last war.
Narrator: Thurgood Marshall was born in Baltimore in 1908, the grandson of a runaway from slavery, the son of a sleeping-car porter and a teacher.
He was a bright, sometimes mischievous child, known for his jokes and pranks.
As punishment for one infraction, the principal of his high school sent him to the basement and told him to read the Constitution.
Barred from the University of Maryland's all-white law school, he went to Howard University instead.
After graduating, Marshall spent a few years in private practice.
In 1936, he was hired by the NAACP.
A colleague remembered Marshall as lean, hard, and Hollywood handsome.
Sherrilyn Ifill: Generations of young people wanted to become lawyers because they saw this vision of lawyer, not the three-piece suit with the pocket watch but the lawyer who spoke in a kind of colloquial smile; who was smoking the cigarette; who had the skinny tie; who had a sense of humor, and, you know, who was--who was cool.
Are you in favor of interracial marriage?
If I can be facetious, I'd like to say that I believe that any man has a right to marry any woman he wants to marry, if she's willing to marry him with one exception.
That's my wife.
Let's turn now to some criticisms of the NAACP.
There are plenty.
Ifill: When we talk about this man and we see him, we can be disarmed by his sense of humor, by his absolute comfort in his own skin.
But we should never forget the kind of courage that lay behind that veneer of, kind of, casualness.
Wallace: Have you ever been confronted with violence or something?
Have you ever been spat upon?
Have you ever been attacked personally?
Well, I have been-- mob had me in Columbia, Tennessee, one time, and there have been remarks passed, and a couple times, I've managed to get away.
How have you conducted yourself?
Narrator: In 1946, Marshall went to Columbia, Tennessee, to represent two dozen men, many of them veterans of World War II, who had been charged with attempted murder after defending themselves from attacks by local police and the Ku Klux Klan.
Against all odds, Marshall managed to get them acquitted.
It was a highly charged case, and as soon as the verdicts were announced, he was anxious to get out of town.
Gilbert King: After the verdict, Marshall gets in the car with some Black reporters and some NAACP lawyers.
They're driving out of town, and they see a police roadblock.
And they have to stop the car, and the police end up dragging Thurgood Marshall out of the car, throwing him into a police car, and driving him down to Duck River.
Marshall: I remember distinctly that I sat in the back of the car, being carried down to the river bottoms, and I remembered that I whistled, but I never remembered what I whistled.
King: And Marshall is sitting in the back sandwiched between two deputies, and he looks out, and what does he see?
A big tree with a bunch of white people underneath it.
And at that point, he just figures, "This is it.
This is where I'm going to be lynched myself."
♪ Fortunately, in this case, the Black reporters and lawyers disobeyed police and followed Marshall's car down to the river, where they thought there would be--now be too many witnesses.
This is Thurgood Marshall, a future Supreme Court Justice, and he's nearly lynched by the side of a river for practicing law.
He would be hailed in local communities in the South as a great hero, as so brave and so courageous.
And no doubt, he was.
But, he would say, "I'm not courageous, "because when this trial is over, "I'm going to be on the first train back to my home "in New York.
"The courageous people are the ones who live here, "who have to stay, who take the risk of having me represent them "and then who stay here and live in this community "for whatever are the consequences, for good or for ill."
Narrator: In 1949, Marshall and the NAACP decided to take on an explosive case involving four young Black men in Lake County, Florida, in the town of Groveland.
Carol Greenlee: My father, Charles Greenlee, was one of the Groveland Four.
He was a kind, gentle, caring person, a family person.
And he loved time with his children.
Narrator: In July of 1949, a few months before Carol Greenlee was born, her father, Charles, 16 years-old, heard from his friend Ernest Thomas that citrus growers in Groveland were hiring.
Carol Greenlee: All he knew is he was going down to the grove to pick oranges and to make money because he's done left a 15-year-old back at home pregnant, getting ready to deliver in November.
Narrator: When they got to Groveland, Ernest invited Charles to come home with him that evening to meet his family.
And Daddy told him, "No, go get me a clean shirt first," you know, "And I'll stay here until you come back."
Narrator: That would take some time.
And since Charles was a stranger in town, Ernest loaned him an empty pistol to warn off anyone who gave him trouble.
Then Charles went to sleep near the train depot, using his suitcase as a pillow.
Carol Greenlee: And that's when the night watchman sees Daddy and sees that he had this old gun in his pocket, and takes him to jail.
[Jail door shuts] The night watchman tells him, "Well, boy, if nothing else around here has happened, "we'll let you go home, but we gotta take you in now until we check things out."
He said, "From the time I was arrested, I thought I was going home the next day."
[Vehicle engine sputtering] Narrator: That same evening, not far from the jail where Greenlee was being held, two World War II veterans, Sam Shepherd and Walter Irvin, came upon a white couple whose car had broken down, Willie Padgett and his 17-year-old wife Norma.
King: Walter Irvin and Sam Shepherd start to help out with the car.
And Norma Padgett tries to share some of her whiskey with the two Black men.
And the husband sees that and gets furious, starts making some racial remarks about how he's not going to drink after a Black person.
And there's a fight that ensues.
And Willie is left laying in a ditch.
And Walter Irvin and Sam Shepherd take off in their cars, leave him there.
Well, Norma Padgett and Willie decide to put together this story that something happened to them that night and they were attacked by four Black men.
Narrator: Norma Padgett told the police four Black men had beaten her husband and raped her, but she said she could not identify any of them.
Willis McCall, the local sheriff, took charge of the case.
Maurice Chammah: Willis McCall epitomizes the power of the sheriff in the American South.
Sheriffs emerged in early America as a kind of police leader that is the highest law enforcement figure in that county, and is also directly elected by the people.
So, sheriffs come to be this very specific, very American blend of policing and politics.
And they are given a very free rein in terms of how they deal with crime.
Willis McCall had no incentive to be a good homicide detective, a good sexual assault detective, as we might imagine today.
He was there to find scapegoats for accusations of crimes, but, really, most importantly, to preserve the power structure as it existed in that county.
King: The sheriff really takes the case from Norma Padgett and says, "Oh, you say there's four men?
I know exactly who they are."
And he starts rounding up troublemakers in the town.
Narrator: Sam Shepard and Walter Irvin were arrested and brought to the county jail.
McCall already had Charles Greenlee in custody, and now he needed just one more suspect to match Norma's story.
He decided to bring in Charles' friend, Ernest Thomas, who had run afoul of the sheriff for running an illegal lottery without making the proper payoffs.
King: Ernest Thomas saw what was happening.
He knew the safest place for him was anywhere but Lake County, and so he fled.
Narrator: McCall led a posse of 1,000 men to track Thomas down.
Carol Greenlee: They hunted him down and put 400 bullets in him under a tree, unarmed man.
He was running from them.
Narrator: McCall told the press that when he was killed, Thomas had a loaded pistol in his hand.
King: There was a letter written by the man who owned that gun to the Sheriff's Department saying it was used to place near the body of Ernest Thomas.
"I'm wondering if I can get it back."
Narrator: In the meantime, word had spread that McCall had suspects in custody.
And outside the county jail, a mob gathered.
King: They are demanding those men be released to the crowd, which is, basically, a lynching about to happen.
And Sheriff Willis McCall stands out in front of the courthouse and says there's not going to be a lynching in Lake County.
"I've moved those men to safety.
"We're going to give these boys a fair trial, and then we're going to put them in the electric chair."
And he was, you know, calling for their death even before they were tried and convicted.
The death penalty, when it's done legally and officially, is only a baby step removed from mob justice and lynching.
Throughout the 1930s, '40s, '50s, lynchings are replaced by legal executions-- typically, electrocutions.
The majority of people sentenced to death and executed in that era were Black.
The numbers were even more extreme when you look at the crime of rape.
Carol Greenlee: McCall tried to get a confession from my dad, and he was tortured.
King: They bring each man down the elevator, into the basement of the courthouse.
They suspend them to pipes with handcuffs.
And they just start beating them with rubber hoses, pulling the gun, threatening them.
Carol Greenlee: This went on for hours.
Glass was broken on the bottom of his feet.
And he was swung back and forth, trying to get a confession from him.
And he was beaten all in his privates.
Narrator: After being interrogated, Charles Greenlee and Sam Shepherd confessed to raping Norma Padgett.
Walter Irvin refused.
The local prosecutor charged them all with rape-- a capital crime in the state of Florida.
The three men were held in Raiford Prison while Thurgood Marshall and the NAACP prepared for their trial.
Ladies and gentlemen, a good evening to you.
The Kefauver Committee wound up its last day in New York with the most sensational testimony yet... Narrator: When Tennessee Senator Estes Kefauver invited the networks to televise hearings held by the Committee to Investigate Crime in Interstate Commerce, some 30 million people tuned in.
They stayed home from work and school, crowded into barber shops and department stores-- anywhere they could get a close-up look at corrupt politicians, real-life mobsters, and the men and women who peopled their violent world.
Newsreel reader: A note of glamour is injected into the thrill-packed proceedings by the presence of Virginia Hill, in whose home the late Bugsy Siegel was killed.
Senator: Did you ever get any money from Meyer Lansky?
I never got money from any of those fellas.
None of those fellas?
None of those fellas.
Senator: Mr.
Anastasio, have you ever been arrested?
I don't know what you mean, if I ever was arrested, sir.
I did--was arrested-- You know what I mean.
I ought to have an opportunity of a respectful hearing, Senator, on the things that I know... Narrator: The primary focus of the hearings was what Senator Kefauver called "the lifeblood of organized crime," interstate gambling.
J. Edgar Hoover: Organized gambling is a vicious evil.
It corrupts our youth and blights the lives of our adults.
It becomes a springboard for other crimes-- embezzlement, robbery, and even murder... Narrator: Despite J. Edgar Hoover's denunciation of gambling, he said it was a local problem, best handled by local law enforcement.
He insisted there was no national crime syndicate and therefore no need for federal action.
Instead, the FBI would continue to focus on those suspected of having Communist ties.
In the Bureau's New York office, there were 400 agents assigned to rooting out subversives; just four were tasked with investigating organized crime.
But the hearings showed that crime was organized across state lines, and that the men in charge of it were making tens of millions from gambling, racketeering, and narcotics, as well as from many legal businesses.
They had grown so wealthy and so powerful that they were able to purchase the cooperation of law enforcement and elected officials all across the country.
The committee subpoenaed Meyer Lansky, but the mob's accountant took the Fifth, revealing nothing about the national criminal organization he and Lucky Luciano had created decades earlier.
Luciano was no longer running things.
The man who had taken over from him in New York City was Frank Costello.
Senator Tobey: You were a bootlegger in 1922, later bringing liquor in and arranging to have it brought in from England and Canada.
Is that correct?
No, it's incorrect.
Tobey: And didn't you sell it to people in this country?
Costello: I bought liquor and sold it, but I didn't directly myself transport it.
Tobey: And when you did that you broke the laws and flouted the Constitution, did you not?
Well, I wasn't the only one, Senator.
I didn't ask you that.
You're the only man I'm questioning now, sir.
You're the one man I'm questioning now, and I'm asking Frank Costello.
You must have in your mind some things you've done that you can speak of to your credit as an American citizen.
If so, what are they?
Paid my tax.
[Laughter] Tobey: Now I'm interested to ask you-- Costello: All due respect to the Senate, which I have an awful lot of respect for, I'm not gonna answer another question.
You just--because I'm not under arrest and I'm gonna walk out.
Rafael A. Mangual: In some ways, we admire some of their characteristics-- their charisma, their toughness, their lack of fear.
But a lot of that kind of public sentiment, I think, is a function of distance between them and the brutality of what the criminal underworld actually represents.
And I think once people actually get a sense of it, whether as a victim or as a witness, that changes quite quickly.
That sense of admiration goes away, and you're kind of brought hurtling back toward reality, and understand what some of these individuals are capable of.
Narrator: In its final report, the Kefauver Committee warned of a sinister criminal organization that had grown out of the murderous underworld wars of the Prohibition era.
It was known, the report said, as the Mafia.
Singer: ♪ Well, dig my grave ♪ ♪ With a silver spade ♪ ♪ Well, dig my grave ♪ ♪ With a silver spade... ♪ Voice: No one has ever asked me if I have seen evidence of brutality at Angola.
But I have seen plenty.
There is no trade school, no handicrafts, or arts, not even a library.
A man sentenced here who cannot read or write leaves here the same way.
No effort is made to help him stay out of the penitentiary once he obtains his release.
The penitentiary is a cancer on the soul of every citizen in the state of Louisiana, who knows of the conditions at Angola and has made no effort to remedy them.
Nurse Mary Margaret Daughtry.
Singer: ♪ You know that poor boy ♪ ♪ Is dead and gone... ♪ Narrator: The Louisiana State Penitentiary, Angola, was built on the site of a former plantation, and nearly 100 years after emancipation, it was still run like one.
So were other prison farms across the South: Parchman in Mississippi, Imperial in Texas, and Cummins in Arkansas.
In 1951, to protest the conditions at Angola, 31 prisoners severed their Achilles tendons with razors.
When a reporter asked why they had done it, most gave the same answer: I had to get out from under that stick.
Thompson: Southern prisons were in such terrible, terrible shape, but Northern prisons also were hell holes in the 1950s and '60s.
And this comes to light because prisoners themselves start to stand up.
We see a spate of uprisings.
♪ Newsreel reader: A wave of prison riots in Eastern States is touched off by inmates of the Trenton, New Jersey, Reformatory, and later spreads to Rahway Reformatory, where state troopers take over to restore order.
231 convicts barricade themselves in a prison barracks, holding eight guards as hostage.
While in Michigan, a still more violent outbreak takes place in the penitentiary at Jackson, the largest walled prison in the world.
Only after state troopers armed with machine guns open fire is the main body of prisoners forced back into cells, leaving one dead and seven wounded.
Whatever investigations disclose, the prison uprisings have focused new interest on our penal institutions.
♪ Thompson: The people who are locked inside of those places, the people who society has deemed often the worst of the worst are saying, "Even though we are in here "and even though we are doing what was asked of us, "which is to serve our time, "where does it say in here that we can't have "decent medical care "or that we cannot practice our religion?
"Where does it say that we have somehow checked our right to be free of cruel and unusual punishment?"
What is so kind of fundamental at the core of these rebellions is the simple desire to be treated as human beings.
Narrator: Amidst growing concern about the nation's prisons, many states pledged to reform their agencies.
Some wardens promised to focus on rehabilitation.
The American Prison Association changed its name to the American Correctional Association.
In 1953, a new warden took over the Tennessee State Prison in Nashville.
He encouraged a doo-wop group in the prison to perform, and invited scouts from a new R&B music label, Sun Records, to come hear them.
Singer: ♪ Just walkin' in the rain ♪ ♪ Getting soaking wet ♪ Narrator: The producers were impressed, and, with the warden's permission, brought the singers to their studio in Memphis for a recording session.
They called themselves The Prisonaires.
Their first record, "Just Walkin in the Rain," sold 250,000 copies, and was one of Sun Records' first big hits.
The Prisonaires performed in the governor's mansion, on the radio, and on television.
Prisonaires: ♪ All because my heart ♪ ♪ Still remember you... ♪ ♪ Who-oa, ooh... ♪ Betts: There is something about trying to create art, which is trying to create a story about our life that you might think wasn't possible when all you focused on was, like, the system and the number of people in prison.
I became a poet in prison.
You know what I mean?
So, so for me, I do think that there's a narrative to be said about the musical tradition of folks who came up out of prison.
It's always been that way.
People are literally producing a present for themselves, even if they have life at the back end of their sentence.
Prisonaires: ♪ I can't forget... ♪ ["Dragnet" theme playing] "Dragnet" narrator: Ladies and gentlemen, the story you are about to see is true.
The names have been changed to protect the innocent.
♪ Joe Friday: This is the city.
From one night to the next, it's never the same.
Most of the people have something to add.
A few of them are out to take it away.
In my job, they're the ones who keep you on the move.
I'm a cop.
Bratton: I grew up in the 1950s.
Friday: It was Wednesday, September 28th... The '50s were a wonderful time to be a kid in America, and I was influenced by television and by the cop shows.
And in those days, the cops were portrayed, by and large, as good people.
Narrator: "Dragnet" was TV's first cop show.
Every week, millions tuned in.
Friday, voice-over: It was Sunday, March 9th.
We were working the day watch on a homicide detail.
A man reported the fatal shooting of his wife.
We didn't know how it happened.
We didn't know why it happened.
The husband claimed it was suicide.
The evidence pointed to murder.
♪ Narrator: On "Dragnet," decent, honorable detectives in the Los Angeles Police Department solved crimes and kept the public safe.
[Pistol firing] Narrator: The show could not have been made without the cooperation of the LAPD and its new chief, William Parker.
Like August Vollmer a generation earlier, Parker was tasked with cleaning up corruption and brutality in the department.
He had his work cut out for him.
In the city jail on Christmas Day 1951, just nine days after "Dragnet" premiered, more than 50 of Parker's officers beat seven young men-- five of them Mexican-American-- sending several to the hospital with serious injuries.
Mexican-American Councilman Edward Roybal said 50 other cases of police brutality had occurred in the same district in just the last few months.
Parker defended his men.
Sometimes, he said, police have to use violence to protect the public.
Anyone who accused the department of brutality was putting his officers in a defensive position and causing a dangerous drop in their morale.
The Los Angeles Police Department was a thin blue line, Parker liked to say, protecting the city from anarchy, disorder, and crime.
To maintain that line, Parker deployed many of his men to Mexican-American neighborhoods, and to South Central Los Angeles, where thousands of Black Americans fleeing the Jim Crow South were settling every year.
Bratton: The thin blue line that Bill Parker referred to was this idea that to have the thin blue line, police were going to have to rule that Black community.
And so the LAPD was at war with the African-American community for 50 years, and it was politically tolerated.
Narrator: William Parker and the LAPD's public relations office worked closely with "Dragnet's" producers.
They suggested storylines based on real cases, assigned on-duty uniformed policemen to work as extras, provided police cars and other equipment, and approved all scripts.
Nothing that put the department in a negative light was ever included.
"Dragnet" was a huge hit and became the model for one of television's most enduring genres: the police procedural.
And the LAPD became one of the most respected police departments in the nation.
George Fenneman: He is the Los Angeles Chief of Police, William H. Parker.
So, Chief Parker, would you come in, please, and meet Groucho Marx?
[Applause] Groucho Marx: You know, it's strange.
You and I have attended many of the same affairs, but we've never spoken to each other.
Did you know that?
Well, I think you're right.
I don't recall ever seeing you at any of these affairs.
Of course you didn't see me.
While you were breaking in the front door, I was breaking out the back door.
I'm only kidding, Chief.
After all, you're my guest, and if I'm not careful, someday I may be your guest.
[Laughter] And if I am, remember, Chief, as far as I'm concerned, a rubber hose should only be used for watering the lawn.
[Laughter] Really?
OK.
Do they still use the rubber hose down there?
For watering the lawn.
[Laughter] Well, with all the scientific approach, I assume you've wiped out crime in L.A.
Is that right?
Oh, actually, it's getting worse.
[Laughter] We have a very difficult and serious situation.
It is not a question of the proficiency of the police service.
It's a question of the indulgences of the American people.
You see, crime in America is skyrocketing.
Well, I'm right with you, Chief.
We may kid the police, but I want to tell you, in a serious emergency, it's mighty handy to have one around.
[Laughter] ♪ ♪ Narrator: Walter Irvin, Charles Greenlee, and Sam Shepherd went to trial just two months after Norma Padgett had falsely accused them of rape.
NAACP lawyers come down.
They have no time to prepare.
They can't investigate this.
They can't get ahold of witnesses.
They're being threatened constantly doing this.
Narrator: On the stand, Norma Padgett pointed to Irvin, Shepherd, and Greenlee.
Using a racial epithet, she said those were the men who had raped her.
It's just a travesty of justice.
You have manufactured evidence; you have prosecutorial misconduct; and you have perjury from just about every witness for the state.
You were really depending on twelve white jurors to go against the police and law enforcement, and the prosecutor.
These local people were not going to stand up to law enforcement.
They were just not going to go against the community mores.
It was just not going to happen.
Narrator: The jury found all three defendants guilty.
Irvin and Shepherd were sentenced to death.
Greenlee was given life in prison.
King: Thurgood Marshall said, "That's how you know "when the jury thought your client was innocent.
They only gave him life."
Marshall's entire strategy was like, "We're not going to win here, but we're going to take it to a higher court."
And his idea was to finally get the case before the U.S.
Supreme Court.
That's what he felt was a level playing field.
Narrator: Marshall immediately began preparing an appeal for Irvin and Shepherd, but he advised Greenlee not to risk challenging his conviction.
If he were to go to trial again, he could be sentenced to death.
[Tool hits ground [man speaking indistinctly] Greenlee was sent to the Florida State Road Department, Camp No.
16 in Lake City.
A few months after he got there, Carol was born.
Carol Greenlee: I didn't know my father until I was, like, maybe three or four years old when I saw him in prison.
My mother used to take me to see him on Sunday evening.
And one Sunday, my mother said, when we was on our way back home, "Well, that's our last trip.
Your father said we shouldn't come back again."
I took it as if I had did something wrong and he didn't want to see me anymore.
That stayed with me for a very long time, until my mother said, no.
He said it was just too hard for him to see you in that situation.
Narrator: Marshall and the NAACP appealed Irvin and Shepherd's convictions all the way to the Supreme Court, citing lack of time for defense to prepare a case, and prejudicial publicity that should have led to a change of venue for the trial.
The justices agreed, and overturned their convictions.
The prosecutor announced the state would try Irvin and Shepherd again.
Until then, they would remain on death row at Raiford State Prison.
King: So, you can imagine the reaction in Lake County.
They did not like this.
They saw this as an activist court, imposing their own values on the Southern way of life.
And so, Willis McCall, he does not like the idea of a second trial.
He's sort of made this implicit bargain with the people of Lake County, like, "There's not going to be a lynching in my community.
"We're going to convict them and send them to the electric chair."
And so, now it's kind of in doubt.
Narrator: The night before the second trial was to begin, Sheriff McCall drove to Raiford to pick up Irvin and Shepherd.
He handcuffed them together, put them in the back of his car, and headed to Groveland.
[Vehicle receding] As soon as McCall crossed into Lake County, he pulled over, saying he had a flat tire.
[Vehicle tires rustle] He ordered the two men out of the car and shot them.
[3 gunshots] King: He shoots Sam Shepherd three times, the third bullet going straight between the eyes.
Kills him instantly.
He shoots Walter Irvin twice... [2 gunshots] and Walter Irvin is still alive.
The only thing he can think to do is pretend to be dead.
Willis McCall gets on the radio and says, "Get back here.
get back here.
I got 'em good."
James Yates, the deputy, comes up to the scene, and Walter Irvin is laying there with his eyes closed, trying to pretend to be dead, and he hears the deputy say, "This one ain't dead yet."
At that point, Irvin opens his eyes, and there's a flash, and a bullet is fired, goes clean through his neck.
Miraculously, Walter Irvin is still not dead.
Then they get together, and they say, "We got to make it look like an escape."
And they start ripping Sheriff Willis McCall's clothes.
They pull some hair out of Willis McCall's head and plant it in Sam Shepherd's hand.
And when the witnesses finally come back to the scene, there's that picture that's photographed, and it's all a lie.
Narrator: McCall said both men tried to escape and he had shot them in self-defense.
Walter Irvin was eventually transported to the hospital.
Thurgood Marshall rushed to see him.
King: Irvin's laying there in bed.
There's a court stenographer there, and he's telling a very different story than the one Sheriff Willis McCall told.
Narrator: The NAACP asked the FBI to investigate.
The Bureau analyzed the crime scene and concluded that Irvin was shot while lying on the ground and had not been trying to escape.
They recommended McCall and Yates be charged with murder and attempted murder.
But the Lake County coroner ruled that McCall and Yates had acted in self-defense.
They were never charged.
Thurgood Marshall was outraged.
"This is the worst case of injustice and whitewashing I have come across in my career," he said.
"Was it necessary to shoot two men handcuffed together three times, in 'self-defense'?"
The state gave Walter Irvin one month to recover from his injuries.
The governor of Florida told the judge to offer Irvin a deal: If he pled guilty, he would be sentenced to life in prison.
King: What does Thurgood Marshall say to this?
Best thing he's ever heard, because he's so used to these states killing defendants that anything that can save a life is a victory.
And so, he goes to Walter Irvin, explains the deal, encourages him to take this deal.
Narrator: Irvin was indignant.
"Say that I raped her?"
he told Marshall.
"I didn't.
And I'm not going to say so.
I am not guilty."
Before the trial, Irvin's mother spoke to Marshall.
Marshall: His mother-- Oh, boy-- she came to me and looked me straight in the face.
And she said, "Lawyer, don't you let my boy die, you understand that?"
I could hardly go to sleep.
King: Sad to say, the second trial is very similar to the first: manufactured evidence; perjury; prosecutorial misconduct.
To no one's surprise, Walter Irvin is convicted and sentenced to death.
Narrator: A few years later, a new governor was elected in Florida, and he commuted Walter Irvin's sentence to life in prison.
Meanwhile, donations poured in to the NAACP from people who heard about what happened to the Groveland Four.
The money helped finance the landmark school desegregation case that the NAACP brought to the Supreme Court: "Brown vs.
Board of Education of Topeka, Kansas."
King: For the first time in Marshall's life, he's got this huge coffer to work with.
And you see how it plays out.
He's able to bring in, you know, sociologists, historians.
I think what they end up producing is one of the most impressive Civil Rights documents, the "Brown" Motion.
And I don't think it would have been possible unless Marshall had all of this money and it came in on the back of this Groveland case.
[Mendelssohn's "Wedding March" playing] Voice: The publicly pretended code of morals-- our marriage customs, our sex laws, and our educational and religious systems are based upon an assumption that individuals are much alike sexually and that it is an equally simple matter for all of them to confine their behavior to the single pattern which the mores dictate, but the living world is a continuum in each and every one of its aspects.
The sooner we learn this concerning human sexual behavior, the sooner we shall reach a sound understanding of the realities of sex.
Dr.
Alfred Kinsey.
♪ Narrator: Dr.
Alfred Kinsey, an entomologist at the University of Indiana, surveyed thousands of American men and women about their intimate lives.
The "Kinsey Reports" were a sensation.
Murray: The "Kinsey Report" reveals that there is a gap between the actual sexual behavior of most Americans and the way the law treats the sexual behavior.
Most Americans are not confining it to the heterosexual missionary position in marriage.
95% of American men are committing sexual crimes because they're engaged in oral copulation; they are having sex outside of marriage; they're engaged in sex with people of the same sex.
I mean, there's this wide array of sexual conduct.
And most of this conduct has been criminalized in some way.
And, so, the "Kinsey Reports" actually raise an important question about this overarching concern.
Like, should the criminal law be used to enforce morality?
Or should it be used for something else?
And should we be making conduct that apparently seems quite commonplace the subject of criminal enforcement?
Ella Fitzgerald: ♪ Birds do it ♪ ♪ Bees do it ♪ ♪ Even educated fleas do it ♪ Narrator: Among the "Kinsey Reports'" many revelations was the extent to which homosexuality was a part of American life.
Fitzgerald: ♪ Let's fall in love ♪ [Audience members whistling, applauding] Narrator: But as with abortion, many viewed homosexuality as a threat to the family and the nation.
At no time in the history of any country has a sexual pervert been to the advantage of the country.
I mean, they're not afraid to show it.
They seem as though they're proud of this.
It's just as bad as a convict bragging about a record.
Narrator: The federal government, and many state and local governments, barred homosexuals from employment, convinced that their sexuality made them vulnerable to blackmail by Soviet agents.
Thousands of men and women lost their jobs during what was called the Lavender Scare.
Murray: There is a real social panic around sex and real concern about homosexuality in the 1950s.
It is not only an assault on the traditional family; it's an assault on society.
And the conflation of the Communist with the sex offender and the adulterer or the homosexual, all of this is part of the same complicated stew of post-war ideals, that there are elements of society who are actively working to corrode it from the inside spurs this crackdown on sex offenders, a crackdown on homosexuals.
Voice: "San Francisco Chronicle," May 26, 1955.
Dozens of places, including twenty-two bars, parks, and lonely parking areas were ordered under periodic police patrol yesterday in the renewed drive on homosexuals here.
The locations were in a directive to all district captains, which listed specific measures to be taken in combating the sexual deviate problem.
The directive ordered that obvious homosexuals, of the effeminate type, are to be stopped on the streets and questioned.
Arrests should be made if warranted.
Murray: This is also a condition that many believe is contagious, so there is this very strong feeling that gay men and women are going to convert or recruit innocent children to homosexuality.
Man: 85% of the homosexuals, you cannot tell that they're homosexual.
They look like I do, like any man does.
You'd never know.
They can be anywhere... Announcer: The speaker is Detective Sargent John Sorenson, the man in charge of the Dade County Sheriff's Department Moral Squad.
His audience is an assembly of eighth graders at one of the local junior high schools.
Better to learn it here than experience it on the streets.
So, if any one of you have let yourself become involved with an adult homosexual or with another boy, you better stop quick, because one out of three of you will turn queer.
And you will be caught.
And the rest of your life will be a living hell.
Man: Few Americans know this man, and yet he's an American legal landmark.
He's not a celebrity, nor a member of the affluent society.
He has spent a good part of his life in jail.
He's a four-time loser.
You might say a born loser.
His name is Clarence Earl Gideon.
It is a crime in this country to be poor.
There's probably a million men or more in my age and older... that has no homes.
And they're arrested in all these towns and charged with vagrancy.
And the only crime they've committed is being poor.
Narrator: In 1961, Clarence Gideon was accused of breaking into the Bay Harbor Pool Room in Panama City, Florida, and stealing five dollars and a few bottles of beer and soda.
He was charged with breaking and entering-- a felony offense in the state.
Like half of all defendants in felony cases across the country, Gideon could not afford a lawyer.
He asked the court to appoint one for him.
The judge refused.
The Constitution's promise of counsel applied only to federal defendants.
Murray: Even though there are these constitutional guarantees to a right to counsel, they only apply in federal trials.
So when the state has you in their clutches for a criminal trial, you have a right to a lawyer if you can pay for one.
And so many poor people couldn't actually avail themselves of the opportunity to have a lawyer.
Sharp: Class has always played a role in the criminal justice system.
Class matters.
And your circumstances matter.
There's this saying that you hear from time to time, "All the justice you can afford."
It matters who your lawyer is.
It matters whether or not you've got someone who has the resources to really investigate your case and put on an appropriate defense.
Narrator: Clarence Gideon had to defend himself.
He was found guilty and sentenced to five years.
While serving his time in the Raiford State Prison, he went to the law library, studied the Constitution, and decided to petition the Supreme Court, asking it to extend the right to counsel to the states.
The Justices agreed to hear his case, and assigned an experienced lawyer to argue on Gideon's behalf.
In a unanimous decision, the Court ruled in Gideon's favor.
Voice: The right to counsel may not be deemed fundamental and essential to fair trials in some countries, but it is in ours.
This noble ideal cannot be realized if the poor man charged with crime has to face his accusers without a lawyer to assist him.
Justice Hugo Black.
Narrator: Gideon's guilty verdict was overturned.
The state of Florida decided to try him again.
This time, he was given a defense attorney.
He was acquitted of all charges.
Reporter: The Supreme Court of Florida applied the Gideon rule retroactively, granting new trials to hundreds of prisoners, releasing others outright.
The results: one year after the "Gideon" decision, more than 1,200 inmates of Florida prisons had been freed.
Krasner: I love "Gideon."
I think it's incredibly important.
"Gideon versus Wainwright" said if you're broke, you're supposed to actually get a lawyer to defend you.
Absolute bedrock, essential aspect of what's good about our criminal justice system.
Narrator: But despite the Supreme Court decision, many cities and states failed to provide enough funding for indigent defense.
Public defenders and court-appointed lawyers often carried heavy caseloads, and did not have enough time to investigate or prepare.
[Indistinct conversation] It is inexcusable that we don't pay more-- and by more, I mean a lot more-- for public defenders and for court-appointed attorneys to handle these incredibly important cases.
It cannot just be lip service to an actual right to have substantial assistance when the government wants your things or the government wants your freedom.
Broke people get screwed.
Would you like more?
I mean, that's how it works.
Broke people get screwed.
Operator: Just a moment for the president.
Martin Luther King Jr.
: Thank you very much.
Lyndon Baines Johnson: Yes, Dr.
King?
Yes, Mr.
President.
How are you today?
Well, I'm doing pretty good... One of the great tributes that we can pay in memory of President Kennedy is to try to enact some of the great, progressive policies that he sought to initiate.
Well, I'm going to support them all, and you can count on that.
And I'm going to do my best to get other men to do likewise, and I'll have to have y'all's help.
And I never needed it more than I do now.
Narrator: When Lyndon Johnson became president in 1963, he was determined to make the nation more equitable and more just.
He declared a War on Poverty, and won passage of landmark civil rights bills.
He also appointed Thurgood Marshall to the Supreme Court.
Elizabeth Hinton: Johnson's War on Poverty was his earnest attempt to make America better and to bring the nation closer to its stated ideals.
Johnson had a real desire to improve U.S.
society and to address racism and inequality and took that monumental task on in a way that no other national figures have since.
He argues that the root cause of crime was poverty.
And he saw the War on Poverty as being an essential component to making the U.S.
a safer society and to stopping crime.
Narrator: Putting Johnson's anti-poverty programs into action would take time, and for millions of Black Americans living in American cities, life was not getting any easier.
Although the economy was booming, many struggled to find jobs that paid well enough to support their families, and their interactions with the police were often fraught.
Kevin Boyle: Police forces acted in Black neighborhoods like occupying armies.
They acted with impunity in those neighborhoods month after month; year after year; decade after decade.
Narrator: As frustrations and resentments grew, new leaders emerged.
Malcolm X: We think that the law should respect the Negro community.
The law should protect the Negro community.
The white man is intelligent enough, if he were made to realize how Black people really feel and how fed up we are, without that old compromising sweet-talk.
Tell him how you feel.
Tell him how, what kind of hell you've been catching and let him know that if he's not ready to clean his house up, he shouldn't have a house.
[People speaking at once] [Woman screams] Narrator: In the summer of 1964, allegations of police brutality sparked uprisings in New York City, Philadelphia, and Rochester.
[Indistinct police radio transmission] Then in August of 1965, in the predominantly Black neighborhood of Watts in South Central Los Angeles, California Highway Patrol officers arrested a man named Marquette Frye for driving while intoxicated.
Frye and his family argued with the officers, and a crowd gathered.
[People speaking excitedly] Narrator: Within a few minutes, the traffic stop escalated into a riot.
[Siren] Reporter: By 10:15 p.m., several hundred Negroes had poured into the streets and were now hurling missiles at passenger cars and store windows.
The police tried to scatter the rock throwers and make arrests.
Day and night it raged, the devastation, the burning, the shootings, looting.
Total chaos.
Reporter 2: And the National Guard will be activated and will be moving into the area.
First one drops their hands is a dead man.
Policeman: Drop that purse and get your hands up.
I said, hands up!
Hands up, please.
Get 'em up.
Get your hands up.
[Siren in distance] Bill Wedgeworth: This insurrection has racial overtones, true.
But it also is a civil disobedience, which has been going on not only in Los Angeles but all over the United States.
I'm just getting tired of being pushed around by you white people.
That's all.
Reporter: How pushed around?
How badly?
In what way?
In all kind of ways, as far as Negroes is concerned.
Every time you look around here, people is picking on him.
Just stopping us on the street, kicking in the doors, taking down to the police station, you're kicking our teeth in.
Reporter: What would it take to end it?
What would it take?
To get Chief Parker out for one thing.
And break some of this brutal force these trigger-happy policemen have.
Narrator: The riot lasted six days.
More than 3,900 people were arrested.
1,032 were wounded.
34 were killed.
Chief Parker said the Watts uprising happened because one person threw a rock, and then he said, like monkeys in a zoo, others started throwing rocks.
Parker blamed the civil rights movement for encouraging people to disrespect the police and break the law.
Parker: So you don't have to obey the law if you think it's unjust.
In other words, you say, well, a certain law is unjust because it's a Jim Crow law.
On the other hand, is the law unjust because "I want a pair of shoes and they're in that store and I haven't got the money to buy them, so I can steal them"?
Narrator: Parker received thousands of letters and telegrams from people expressing their support for what the LAPD had done to restore order and put down the riot.
For the rest of the decade, riots and rebellions erupted in city after city.
I think we've got to see that a riot is the language of the unheard, and I contend that the cry of Black power is at bottom a reaction to the reluctance of white power to make the kind of changes necessary to make justice a reality for the Negro.
Lyndon Baines Johnson: The looting and arson and plunder and pillage, which have occurred, are not part of a civil rights protest.
There is no American right to loot stores or to burn buildings or to fire rifles from the rooftops.
That is crime, and crime must be dealt with forcefully.
The criminals who committed these acts of violence against the people deserve to be punished, and they must be punished.
Narrator: In 1967, President Johnson appointed a commission to study violence and civil disorder, led by Illinois Governor Otto Kerner.
They concluded that police brutality was at the root of much of the unrest, and they recommended reforms.
Otto Kerner: Our nation is moving toward two societies, one Black, one white, separate and unequal.
Reaction to last summer's disorders has quickened the movement and deepened the division.
Discrimination and segregation have long permeated much of American life; they now threaten the future of every American.
To pursue our present course will involve the continuing polarization of the American community.
Hinton: The Kerner Commission recognized that in order to prevent riots or rebellion from happening in the future, what was needed was a massive investment in social and economic programs in low-income communities: a complete overhaul of public schools, decent housing units, and perhaps, most importantly, a major, major job creation program for low-income people.
"We need a Marshall Plan for American cities."
But Johnson wanted nothing to do with it.
It was too radical for him.
Narrator: Regardless, Johnson no longer had the political capital he would have needed to do what the Kerner Commission had recommended.
More and more Americans disapproved of his handling of the Vietnam War, which was mired in stalemate, and in the spring of 1968, he announced he would not seek reelection.
Before he left office, Johnson did manage to push through the Fair Housing Act banning discrimination, and, with violent crime rising, won passage of the Omnibus Crime Control and Safe Streets Act, that in the years to come would send billions of federal dollars to the states for police training and equipment.
In April, Martin Luther King Jr.
was assassinated.
Singer: ♪ Ooh... ♪ Narrator: In June, Senator Robert Kennedy was assassinated.
♪ In August, during the Democratic National Convention, there was mayhem on the streets of Chicago, as local police officers and national guardsmen battled with anti-war protesters.
It seemed to many Americans the country was coming apart.
Rolling Stones: ♪ Ooh, a storm is threatening ♪ ♪ My very life today ♪ [Rifles firing] ♪ If I don't get some shelter ♪ ♪ Ooh, yeah, I'm gonna fade away ♪ ♪ War, children ♪ ♪ It's just a shot away ♪ ♪ It's just a shot away ♪ ♪ War, children... ♪ Richard Nixon: Over the last four years, we've had the worst crime wave in the history of America.
Over the last four years, we haven't had one moment of peace abroad.
My friends, I say to you that the American people can't afford four more years of what we've had for the last four years.
[Cheering and applause] Narrator: The Republican nominee for president in 1968, Richard Nixon, made law and order the centerpiece of his campaign.
Nixon: At its current rate, the crimes of violence in America will double by 1972.
We owe it to the decent and law-abiding citizens of America to take the offensive against the criminal forces that threaten their peace and their security, and to rebuild respect for law across this country.
I pledge to you, the wave of crime is not going to be the wave of the future in America.
[Dramatic music] Hinton: Nixon realized that the language of crime and law and order could appeal to the racial fears of that group of Americans that he called "the Silent Majority," who favored a more traditional conservative idea about what American society should be and what American families should look like.
Narrator: Nixon told former President Dwight Eisenhower that his message was resonating in all parts of the country, including areas like New Hampshire, where, he said, there is virtually no race problem and relatively little crime.
In November, Nixon was elected the 37th president of the United States.
In the decades to come, candidates and office-holders across the political spectrum would continue to win elections by stoking Americans' fears, and promising a return to law and order.
As the country became tougher on crime, passing harsher laws and mandating longer sentences, the nation's prison population would steadily rise.
By the end of the 20th century, there would be more people behind bars in the United States than at any time in history.
♪ Narrator: In 1968, nearly 20 years after Norma Padgett had accused him of rape, Walter Irvin was granted parole and released from prison.
King: In 1969, he actually returned to Lake County for an uncle's funeral.
And right before this funeral, he was found dead in the car.
He actually died of natural causes in that car, but a relative told me something that really resonated.
You know, he was shot three times by Sheriff Willis McCall.
Two of those bullets did severe damage to his organs, and that he was continually having health problems in prison.
So he died at the age of 41.
But the relatives wanted me to know that he died from the gun of Willis McCall; It just took him 20 years to die.
Nothing ever happened to Willis McCall.
After he shot two of the Groveland Four on the side of the road, a reporter asked him, like, "Are you worried about your chances here to go on as sheriff after this incident?"
And he just kind of laughed.
And he said, you know, "That incident will probably get me elected four more times."
He was actually wrong.
It got him elected five more times.
Narrator: After 11 years in prison, Charles Greenlee was granted parole, and built a new life in Nashville, Tennessee.
Carol Greenlee: He trained himself as an electrician in prison.
So, when he got out, he had a skill.
And he became an HVAC expert.
He built a great business.
Narrator: Greenlee and his family never spoke about his case.
Carol Greenlee: My family pushed it under the rug because it was a cloud.
The perception is you're a bad person if you're in prison, whether you're there innocently or not.
I think I might have been maybe 40 years old.
I said, "Daddy, you got to tell me one thing: "Did you do this?
Did you do what they say you did?"
And he said, "No.
No, baby.
No."
Narrator: Charles Greenlee died in 2012.
After his death, Carol and the families of the other men began a campaign to clear the names of the Groveland Four.
They gained some traction after Gilbert King published a book about the case, and in 2019, they were granted a pardon hearing before Florida Governor Ron DeSantis and his Cabinet.
Norma Padgett, almost 90, spoke at the hearing.
She pleaded with the board not to pardon the Groveland Four, because, she said, they done it.
Norma Padgett: I'm not no liar.
If I had to go to court today, I could tell you the same story.
Now, I don't want 'em pardoned.
No, I do not.
Carol Greenlee: Ms.
Norma Padgett.
I saw her come in.
She was with her sons.
But I just feel sorry.
I feel sorry.
I wouldn't want to carry that kind of guilt.
I don't have no problem in saying I forgive you, because the ultimate is not with me; it's with you and God.
I can't carry not forgiving people because it's too heavy.
It don't do nothing but keep me down, keep me burdened.
I want to enjoy life.
I want to enjoy happiness.
I want to embrace hope.
Ron DeSantis: While this act cannot write the wrongs done to them many years ago, I hope that it will bring peace to their families and to their communities... Narrator: After the hearing, Governor Ron DeSantis posthumously pardoned Walter Irvin, Charles Greenlee, Sam Shepherd, and Ernest Thomas; two years later, they were exonerated.
The state attorney announced that he had never witnessed a more complete breakdown of the criminal justice system than what happened to the Groveland Four.
Carol Greenlee: I had to scream that day.
It was like the ocean had lifted up off of me.
It was like the... the bells of heaven had started to ringing.
I couldn't hold it back.
My daddy was free.
The world will know that my daddy is innocent, is not a rapist.
The truth is being told.
And all I can say is hallelujah.
♪ ♪ ♪ Announcer: Next time on "Crime and Punishment in America"... Clarence B. Jones: When they get incarcerated, they don't cease being human beings.
Heather Ann Thompson: In the wake of Attica, people were horrified.
Stephen B. Walker: Training was to look at something and recognize the potential danger.
It was about custody and control.
Annie Nichol: I understand wanting punishment as a victim, but what if more options were available?
Announcer: When "Crime and Punishment in America" continues next time.
Announcer: Scan this QR code with your smart device to dive deeper into the story of "Crime and Punishment in America" with interactives, classroom materials, and more.
Announcer: The "Crime and Punishment in America" DVD is available online and in stores.
The series is also available with PBS Passport and on Amazon Prime Video.
The digital companion soundtrack is also available online.
♪ ♪ Announcer: Major funding for "Crime and Punishment in America" was provided by... The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and the Park Foundation.
Major funding was also provided by the following members of The Better Angels Society: The Fullerton Family Charitable Fund, The Just Trust for Education, Allan and Shelley Holt, The Tow Foundation, and the Sozosei Foundation.
Additional support was provided by the National Endowment for the Humanities, The Arthur Vining Davis Foundations, and by The Better Angels Society members: John and Catherine Debs, Timothy Fazio, Lise Strickler and Mark Gallogly, the Laurie M. Tisch Illumination Fund, and these additional funders.
"Crime and Punishment in America" was made possible, in part, by contributions to your PBS station from Viewers Like You.
Thank you.
'Criminal justice ... is as much about regulating morals' as safety
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep3 | 38s | The criminal justice system is weaponized to police morals and regulate women's autonomy. (38s)
Dragnet, the Thin Blue Line, and Improving the LAPD's Image
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep3 | 5m 16s | LAPD Chief William Parker works with the TV show Dragnet to improve the department's public image. (5m 16s)
Fred Korematsu Fights Internment
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep3 | 10m 47s | Fred Korematsu defies President Roosevelt's order to detain everyone of Japanese descent. (10m 47s)
J. Edgar Hoover and the FBI Fight the War on Crime
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep3 | 7m 17s | To win the new war on crime, the FBI sets their sights on famous targets like John Dillinger. (7m 17s)
Prisoners Riot to Protest Poor Conditions and Abuse
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep3 | 5m 32s | There is a string of prison uprisings as prisoners protest abuse and unfair living conditions. (5m 32s)
Richard Whitney and the Investigation of White Collar Crime
Video has Closed Captions
Clip: Ep3 | 6m 22s | The Senate Banking Committee investigates Richard Whitney and other white collar criminals. (6m 22s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSupport for PBS provided by:
Episodes presented in 4K UHD on supported devices. Major funding for CRIME AND PUNISHMENT IN AMERICA was provided by The Atlantic Philanthropies, Emerson Collective, The Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, and...






















